Patreon has been the top choice for creators who want to earn recurring income from fans. But in 2025, it is far from the only option. Memberful is another powerful membership platform that, interestingly, was acquired by Patreon in 2018. Memberful is a strong alternative for creators who want more control over their brand and customer experience.
Both platforms help you monetize your audience, but they take very different approaches. Patreon is simple, plug-and-play, and community-driven, while Memberful is a white-label solution that integrates directly with your own website.
So, which one should you choose? In this article, we’ll compare Patreon vs Memberful in 2025, covering pricing, features, fees, pros, cons, and the types of creators best suited for each.
Quick Comparison: Patreon vs Memberful
Patreon Overview
Best for: Creators who want a simple, all-in-one solution without much setup
Pricing: Free to start, but takes 10% of earnings + payment processing fees
Patreon remains the biggest name in creator memberships. It is trusted by millions of fans and thousands of creators across niches like music, podcasts, art, and writing.
In 2025, Patreon offers:
- Tier-based memberships (with perks for fans)
- Built-in content hosting (posts, audio, video, polls)
- Fan community tools (comments, messaging, Discord integration)
- Mobile apps for creators and fans
- Creator-focused analytics
Why Creators Like Patreon:
- No setup headaches, you can launch in a few hours.
- Familiar brand, fans know and trust Patreon.
- Built-in discovery means new fans may stumble upon you.
- Everything is hosted in one place (no need for a separate site).
Pros:
- Very beginner-friendly
- Huge audience already familiar with Patreon
- Strong community features
- Integrated mobile apps
Cons:
- High fees (up to 10% + processing)
- Limited customization (Patreon branding dominates)
- Payouts can be slow
- Less control over your fan relationships (Patreon owns the data)
Memberful Overview
Best for: Creators who already have a website and want full control
Pricing: $49/month + 4.9% transaction fee + Stripe fees
Memberful is a white-label membership software designed for creators who want to run everything under their own brand. Instead of living on Patreon’s platform, your membership system integrates directly into your site, keeping fans within your ecosystem.
In 2025, Memberful offers:
- Full integration with WordPress (and other CMS’)
- Membership tiers and paywalls for your own site
- Support for digital downloads and private podcasts
- Stripe integration for payments
- Complete white-label branding
Why Creators Like Memberful:
- Fans never leave your site, it’s all under your name.
- You own your audience, branding, and customer relationships.
- Works well for established creators with an existing following.
- Stripe handles payments securely and globally.
Pros:
- Full branding and control
- Seamless WordPress integration
- Professional checkout experience
- Great for digital products and podcasts
Cons:
- Monthly fee plus transaction fees
- No discovery tools, growth depends on you
- Requires technical setup and maintenance
- Not ideal for beginners without a website
Patreon vs Memberful: Pricing Breakdown
Patreon:
- Free to start, but charges a flat 10% fee on revenue
- Payment processing fees: ~2.9% + $0.30 per transaction.
- Example: If you earn $1,000/month, Patreon would take $100 after Stripe takes $30.
Memberful:
- $49/month subscription fee + 4.9% transaction fee + Stripe fees (~2.9% + $0.30).
- Example: If you earn $1,000/month, you’ll pay about $130 total ($49 subscription + fees).
- The higher your earnings, the better Memberful’s flat fee structure becomes compared to Patreon’s percentage-based cuts.
Verdict: Patreon is cheaper for small creators earning under ~$500/month, while Memberful becomes more cost-effective for creators scaling past that.
Patreon vs Memberful: Features
Patreon vs Memberful: Ease of Use
- Patreon: Very beginner-friendly. Anyone can set up a page in under an hour. The trade-off is limited customization.
- Memberful: More complex. You’ll need a website (usually WordPress) and some technical setup. But once integrated, it feels professional and seamless.
Patreon vs Memberful: Who Should Use Each?
- Patreon is better for:
- Beginners who don’t want technical setup
- Creators who don’t yet have a website
- Artists, musicians, and podcasters just starting out
- Those who want discovery and a built-in audience
- Memberful is better for:
- Established creators with an existing fanbase
- Bloggers, podcasters, and educators with websites
- Creators who care about full branding control
- Businesses scaling beyond hobby-level income
Patreon vs Memberful: Pros and Cons Summary
Which One Should You Choose?
The choice between Patreon and Memberful comes down to your stage as a creator and your long-term goals.
- If you’re just starting out and want something quick, simple, and community-oriented, Patreon is the easiest choice. You can be up and running in hours, and fans are already familiar with the platform.
- If you already have a website, a solid following, and you want control and scalability, Memberful is the smarter option. While it requires more setup, it pays off in lower long-term fees and brand independence.
Some creators even use both: Patreon for discovery and casual supporters, and Memberful for their most dedicated fans who want a premium, branded experience.
Final Thoughts
Patreon and Memberful both help you monetize your audience, but they serve different types of creators. Patreon is beginner-friendly and community-oriented, while Memberful is professional and brand-focused.
In 2025, the deciding factor is whether you want simplicity (choose Patreon) or control (choose Memberful). Either way, what matters most is choosing a platform that matches your creative style, audience size, and long-term vision.
(can change CTA here to "start free trial")
